Jane Urquhart – The Underpainter

 

For the past year I have belonged to a book group here in Switzerland. This is by far the best book group I have ever had the luck to join. We’re an international group of women who meet once a month in one of the region’s wine caveaus – a beautiful smoky cellar filled with wine casks and gnarled old vines in a village that dates to Roman times. We do a tasting and talk literature for a few hours – it is an evening I look forward to all month and I am never disappointed. Last month we discussed Marilynne Robinson’s Gilead and this month David Mitchell’s Cloud Atlas is on the schedule – I cannot wait.

Sometime last year we read Jane Urquhart’s A Map of Glass which was my introduction to this Canadian writer. On the whole we were a divided group. Some of us loved the book and others a bit less. I was in the second camp. Something about the novel put me off. It is a beautifully written story and deals with emotional distance and artistic expression in an intriguing way – which might have been the problem. Like my more recent experience with Don Delillo’s Falling Man, when a character keeps his or her distance from me, I tend to respond a lot less as well. While reading it, I kept telling myself that I should love it but something held me back. However, Urquhart’s stunning and skillful writing told me that I had found an author I might like to try again.

When I saw another Jane Urquhart, The Underpainter, on one of the awards lists for the Book Awards Reading Challenge I added her to my list and I am so glad that I did. What was even more interesting about this read was that although the story is extremely different, the themes in The Underpainter are very similar to those in A Map of Glass – emotional distance and the artistic mediation of that same distance.

The story is narrated by an elderly painter named Austin and covers a large span of his life, from his childhood into his forties. I mentioned yesterday that this book reminds me of Les Ames Grises and this is mostly because the tone of the narrator is so similar – such sorrow and regret, and such a need to account for his life. Austin circles in and out of his own story and the story of one of his friends – George. The two stories are, of course, linked far more deeply than is initially expected. And the way Urquhart moves us through these men’s lives is so adept, each new experience echoing another.

Writing a novel about a completely unlikable character who needs the reader’s sympathy for the story to work is difficult and Austin was one of the most difficult characters to get on with I have ever read. He made me angry before I managed to feel sorry for him and it took me a long time to forgive him but this serves the story’s purpose in a clever way. So all I can do now is admire how Urquhart pulled it off.

The Underpainter is essentially a love story. But that completely reduces all that is actually contained in its pages – yes, it is about Austin and Sara, his artistic muse, it is also about George and Vivian and later Augusta (one of the book’s most interesting characters), but it is also about the trauma of WWI, about choosing whether to observe life or experience it, and it is most definitely about artistic passion and how different individuals manifest and serve that passion.

Advertisements

Published by

Michelle

Reader, writer, translator, nature-lover, happy expat and concerned world citizen.

7 thoughts on “Jane Urquhart – The Underpainter”

  1. I’m always impressed when an author can convince me to like a character that I start out being angry with.

    I read Cloud Atlas recently, and I was BLOWN away. It started kinda slow for me with the man on the ship, but once I got past that first chapter, I was hooked.

  2. “a beautiful smoky cellar filled with wine casks and gnarled old vines in a village that dates to Roman times”

    wow, what an incredible place to have a book group and tasting. sounds lovely!

  3. J – Me too. I think it exceptionally hard to lead a reader in one direction and then bring them back without cheating – and Urquhart did.

    I am exactly halfway finished with Cloud Atlas and I LOVE it. I can’t wait for all the stories to start going backward.

    Snackywombat – It is a great place and we all feel really lucky to have found the spot.

  4. That sounds like the best book group ever. I used to have the most wonderful book group, and then we moved, and I keep thinking I should start one here. But then I think that there’s no way it can measure up to my old one, and I’ll be stuck, since I started it. So I wait for someone to invite me into one, but so far no one has. It’s a huge reason I started my blog, really.

  5. Stefanie – It was just lovely. I’d love to hear what you think. And I am LOVING Cloud Atlas. I should finish up today – what a unique book.

    Dewey – I am so lucky to have found this book group. If you do move to Switzerland you’d be a very welcome member 🙂 I started this blog around the same time that I joined the book group so it was clear that I needed as much ‘book talk’ as I could get!

    Dorothy – I just feel so fortunate to have found the group. It is definitely one of my favorite nights of the month.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s