Achilles has a dilemma – Book Nine

I finished Book Nine of The Iliad last evening. What a significant chapter. One that, I think, really gets to the heart of what The Iliad is really about. 

This book is titled The Embassy to Achilles and it covers the moment when Agamemnon sends his most trusted advisors to broker a treaty with Achilles. At this point, the Achaeans have been fighting pretty seriously for quite some time in the renewed battle and they are exhausted. Achilles has been nursing his rage and wounded pride in his tents. The Achaeans really need him. And Agamemnon comes out with an offer that seems pretty fair. He’s not only willing to give back what he unjustly took from Achilles, he’s willing to bestow a myriad of other gifts as well. In essence, he’s agreeing to magnify Achilles’s kleos to a significant degree.  

It was the loss of this kleos that we are meant to believe is the whole reason why Achilles has been abstaining from the war. Except in this chapter he refuses Agamemnon’s offer and admits to a more troubling reason altogether: 

Mother tells me / the immortal goddess Thetis with her glistening feet / that two fates bear me on to the day of death. / If I hold out here and I lay siege to Troy, / my journey home is gone, but my glory never dies. / If I voyage back to the fatherland I love, / my pride, my glory dies… / true, but the life that’s left me will be long, / the stroke of death will not come on me quickly. 

What a decision Achilles has to make. Long life and no glory or accept that a glorifying death will come to him soon and he’ll be revered as one of the greatest fighters of all time. I know that Achilles will eventually be impelled to join the fighting when he loses his friend Patrocles, but I find his hesitancy and his fear in these chapters quite touching. Who wouldn’t stop a moment and really think about how to proceed? He hasn’t seen his homeland in nearly ten years, it seems natural to me that he might be more than a little homesick. And that he might kindof prefer the idea of a quiet death surrounded by his loved ones.  

Achilles is a fascinating character because he’s half god and half human. I think The Iliad makes a careful exploration of this idea by rendering him more human as the story gains momentum. Wrath – which removes him from his fellow soldiers, is such a god-like emotion. Fear – which keeps him away, is much more human. And grief – which will eventually drive him right back into the thick of the fighting, is even more so.

Advertisements

Published by

Michelle

Reader, writer, translator, nature-lover, happy expat and concerned world citizen.

6 thoughts on “Achilles has a dilemma – Book Nine”

  1. I can’t resist leaving you Philip Roth’s take on Achilles, via his Classics professor, Coleman Silk. This is how he describes him: ‘‘Adrenal Achilles: the most highly flammable of explosive wildmen any writer has ever enjoyed portraying; especially where his prestige and his appetite are concerned, the most hypersensitive killing machine in the history of warfare. Celebrated Achilles: alienated and estranged by a slight to his honour. Great heroic Achilles who, through the strength of his rage at an insult – the insult of not getting the girl – isolates himself, positions himself defiantly outside the very society whose glorious protector he is and whose need of him is enormous.’ I just love that. I like the doubt and the humanity that you read in him too.

  2. Amateur Reader – Absolutely, they managed to reveal how much humanity could be seen in the gods and how much immortality we had in ourselves.

    Litlove – thank you for that! It’s just wonderful and I love the line about him being the most hypersensitive killing machine in the history of warfare, pegs him just perfectly.

  3. Now, of course, Shakespeare just makes a great big sulking baby out of him and casts all sorts of aspersions on his relationship with Patrocles. You really get the feeling he didn’t appreciate him. I wonder if he’d seen someone at court he was having a pop at?

  4. Ann – I haven’t read Troilus and Cressida and I really think I should read it as soon as I finish The Iliad – what a good idea, thank you!

  5. I like your take on Achilles, that his emotions play such a defining role in who he is–god and human. I never thought of that when I read The Iliad. I just thought he was a big cry-baby 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s