Michelle Bailat-Jones

Writer, Translator, Reader

Oneworld Classics, which is rapidly becoming one of my favorite publishing programs, recently republished (2008) a novel by the Scottish writer Alexander Trocchi. The novel, Young Adam, was originally published in 1954 and features a highly-unreliable narrator named Joe.

Young Adam is divided into three parts and it isn’t until you turn the page to Part 2 that you realize that Joe has just spent eighty pages distracting you from the real story. The novel actually opens with Joe and his employer Leslie finding a dead woman floating in the river next to their barge. They fish her out, call the police, mull over the event a bit and then the novel changes direction completely, detailing Joe’s obsessed attempt to have an affair with Leslie’s wife.

But when Part 2 opens, you realize that Joe and the dead woman are much more intricately connected than he ever let on. And that the novel is actually about this relationship and Joe’s role in her death. You also realize that Joe’s interest in Leslie’s wife Ella dates from almost the exact moment the other woman’s body was removed from the river and that previous to that moment, he hadn’t much considered her worth his time. 

Although quite a short novel, Young Adam packs a bizarrely powerful punch. On the one hand, the writing is often awkward. Joe’s narrative style is as inconsistent as his fact-telling. He moves from a gentle, poetic lyricism to using stilted, clumsy sentences – often in the same paragraph. The introduction tells me that Trocchi did this on purpose, and links it to his proto-postmodern style. I must admit that it created a bumpy reading experience, although I eventually accepted this as part of Joe’s camouflage, a way to deceive or at least confuse the reader. On the other hand, Joe’s attempts to disentangle himself from the responsibility of the woman’s death are psychologically rich and complex and gave a lot of meat to this very slim story.

Joe’s relationship with the different women in the novel is where Trocchi seems to provide most of the analysis for Joe’s character. Joe is profoundly misogynistic. Although this may be oversimplifying things, since he also seems to be just as misanthropic. I couldn’t find an example of Joe enjoying the company of any other single person in the novel. But he uses the women in particular, which makes it easier to examine this aspect of his personality.

Trocchi is considered a member of the Beat generation and Young Adam reflects that tradition, although I found it much darker than other samples of Beat literature I’ve come across. I wonder if this is a cultural difference, since I often find that Europeans allow for a more cynical and somber worldview than Americans. In his literature, Trocchi seems to be experimenting with both form and content, but there is no joy, no heady giddiness in that experimentation.

In fact, it could be argued that his portrayal of sexual freedom results in a heartless, unfeeling situation where both partners are locked inside their own experience, without access to the other. If Trocchi was interested in exploring the Beat themes of rootlessness, non-conformity and free expression, his assessment of the power granted in that freedom seems overwhelmingly pessimistic.

 In total, Trocchi has ten novels, although it seems most of these are dismissed as experimental erotic fiction with little literary merit. His other “serious” novel, Cain’s Book, is a chronicle of heroin addiction and caused quite a sensation when it was first published in 1961. Apparently, critics are still undecided as to whether Young Adam or Cain’s Book should be considered his finest work. I’ll be interested to see what I think when I can get my hands on a copy.

7 Responses to “Alexander Trocchi – Young Adam”

  1. Lilian Nattel

    That’s interesting. I don’t think I’ve ever read any Beat literature (not even Kerouac). I agree that Europeans allow for a more sombre view than Americans (who also take much more prozac per capita).

  2. ds

    Hmmm…A Scottish Beat writer. Different. I did read On the Road; this seems to belong on another shelf. But I agree with you and Lillian; Europeans are not as dismayed by pessimism (but then, they have never officially declared the Pursuit of Happiness as an agenda).

  3. verbivore

    Lilian – Kerouac is really the only Beat I have any experience with and he’s a bit hit and miss for me. I enjoyed his novella Tristessa, but never liked On the Road or Dharma Bums very much. I must admit the Beats never interested me very much, but Trocchi presents a different way of looking at their work and I enjoyed that.

    Ds – So true! I had a Prof in grad school who refused to study American modernists in the same section as European modernists, he claimed the experiences and the aesthetic were so completely different there was little basis for comparison.

  4. Table Talk

    This is both an unknown writer and an unknown press as far as I’m concerned and I’m off now to explore the publisher and see what other goodies they have to offer. I will definitely be looking out for ‘Young Adam’ as one of my research interests is the way in which writers play around with the reader’s expectations in respect of the shape and emphasis of the plot. Thanks for the review.

  5. litlove

    Interesting. I rather think they made a film of this with Ewan McGregor or someone similar. It sounds a difficult read, but a rewarding one.

  6. Stefanie

    This sounds good. Oneworld Classics is becoming a favorite publisher of mine too. They do good work.

  7. verbivore

    Ann – I think you would really like Oneworld Classics, they have some excellent excellent books and their format is just lovely. Affordable too!

    Litlove – A film? Interesting, I’d be curious to see how it worked. Very dark, I imagine. And I can see McGregor doing well in the part.

    Stefanie – They most definitely do. I’d love to order their entire catalogue one of these days. 🙂

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: