Barbara Comyns – The Vet’s Daughter
Almost ten years ago, I happened upon a book in a used bookstore in Urbana-Champaign, IL with a funny title: Our Spoons Came from Woolworths. I took it home out of curiosity and over the next few days delighted in the discovery of a wonderfully distinct literary voice. I’d never read quite anything like it—breathless like Woolf, but more fanciful, and yet extremely sharp and clear. (Some people might describe Woolf as fanciful, but I think Woolf is too intellectual to be fanciful… she’s playful, but it’s always intellectual. Comyns has a dash of fantasy, of magic, yet her writing is never incomprehensible.) At the same time, there was a sadness to the writing that made it all very interesting and mysterious. I have held on to this first impression of Barbara Comyns’s writing, eager to read more, and yet for some inexplicable reason, hadn’t done so.
So I was delighted to stumble across a NYRB volume of her novel The Vet’s Daughter (begun around 1952, published in 1959) at a used bookstore in Lausanne last week. Nothing gives a better sense of her writing than to read the first two paragraphs:
A man with small eyes and a ginger moustache came and spoke to me when I was thinking of something else. Together we walked down a street that was lined with privet hedges. He told me his wife belonged to the Plymouth Brethren, and I said I was sorry because that is what he seemed to need me to say and I saw he was a poor broken-down sort of creature. If he had been a horse, he would have most likely worn kneecaps. We came to a great red railway arch that crossed the road like a heavy rainbow; and near this arch there was a vet’s house with a lamp outside. I said, “You must excuse me,” and left this poor man among the privet hedges.
I entered the house. It was my home and it smelt of animals, although there was lino on the floor. In the brown hall my mother was standing; and she looked at me with her sad eyes half-covered by their heavy lids, but did not speak. She just stood there. Her bones were small and her shoulders sloped; her teeth were not straight either; so, if she had been a dog, my father would have destroyed her.
That last line is devastating, isn’t it? And this illustration of her father’s cruelty is just one of many to come. Our narrator Alice is a gentle, and somewhat naïve soul. She isn’t naïve in the sense that she isn’t aware of unpleasant realities or even that she is locked up inside herself, a victim, as it were. Instead, she is observant, thoughtful and emotionally intelligent, yet her upbringing has left her sheltered enough to believe she might stand a chance at happiness. The book follows Alice through the death of her mother, a move away from London to work as a lady’s companion for a colleague of her father, possible love and an eventual return to her father’s home. There is also a very gentle supernatural plot line as Alice discovers she has the ability to levitate, a talent that will determine her future.
That Alice can levitate is not without a symbolic function in the story. For without any other viable option, Alice has found the means to free herself from a “heavy” existence. This shows an incredible courage on Alice’s part. I also can’t help reading this as a very sly and perhaps inadvertant social critique—except for Alice’s levitation, the novel is unfailingly realistic, and we all know that levitation is truly impossible. So it is only in fiction that Alice can escape her fate…and well, you have to read the end of the book to know that this escape is not without a high price.
Now that I’ve read two of her eleven novels, I can’t help comparing her to other writers working at the same time: Lessing (The Grass is Singing, 1950), Gordimer (The Lying Days, 1953), Murdoch (Under the Net, 1954), Pym (Excellent Women, 1952). Accepting Pym as the stylistic outlier here, there is still a strong connection between all these writers, especially along socio-political preoccupations. A connection that Comyns does not share. Comyns seems completely uninterested in engaging with the socio-political except in the way that it organically touches her narrators. Her world appears to be completely and dramatically sealed around the narrator’s consciousness. In this sense, and especially with the light touch of supernatural/magical, she reminds me of the Carson McCullers of The Ballad of the Sad Café (1951).
It goes without saying that I’ll be reading more Comyns. A really lovely small press called Dorothy recently re-issued her 1955 novel Who Was Changed and Who was Dead. And I have it on good authority (Jess Stoner, David Auerbach) that this is one of, if not her best…
11 Responses to “Barbara Comyns – The Vet’s Daughter”
Oh this sounds excellent! I just heard of comyns for the first time a few months ago and thought she sounded intriguing. Now I am really going to need to make an effort to read her.
What a fascinating review–I’m intrigued by that sort of symbolic magical touch dropped into realism. I like it.
Stefanie – I highly recommend her, and think she will suit your reading tastes as well. Can’t wait to see what you think.
Lilian – The subtle magical touch is in both books (and I’ve heard it’s in the others as well), so I believe it is part of her style. I think you would enjoy her work.
I am an ardent Comyns fan and am always delighted when someone else enjoys her work. I enjoyed your review, and I like your point ‘Her world appears to be completely and dramatically sealed around the narrator’s consciousness’.
‘Who was Changed and Who Was Dead’ is my favourite (I think!); it’s quite different in subject from the two you’ve read and I am sure you’ll love it…
Very excited to read Who was Changed and Who was Dead now… this really seems to be her best. But I wonder, should I read all of her work and finish with this one? Hmmmm…
For some reason, I hesitate over Comyns. I think it’s because I find her cold, and the psychological depth seems to be portrayed through symbols and whimsy. But you know, I should really try and read a whole book before saying such things, right? 😉 Knowing that you appreciate her does make me more determined to give her a proper try.
Which book did you try to read? I think your comment about her being “cold” is an interesting one, I do find some of her writing clipped, even clinical, but it strikes me as coming from the quickness of her thinking, or the movement from one moment to the next, which she does not hesitate over. There is nothing lingering about her writing, if that makes sense.
But if you do decide to try her again, I’d love to know what you think. Perhaps her, Who Was Changed and Who Was Dead might be a place to start, as it seems to come so highly recommended.
Michelle! If you haven’t already bought Who Was Changed, DON’T! I’ll send you my copy!
I haven’t yet – was going to order it from SPD with your book at the same time 🙂 But you’re awesome if you’d send me the Comyns! Thank you!
Consider it done! Email me your address (I’m sure I have it somewhere, but this’ll be easier). I’ll throw in a copy of my book too!
[…] Barbara Comyns novel that I’ve read. I started with Our Spoons Came from Woolworths, then went to The Vet’s Daughter and after that read The Juniper Tree. My reading of her has been completely haphazard, dictated […]
Comments are closed.